Todd Phillips’ Joker: Folie à Deux, starring Joaquin Phoenix and Lady Gaga, isn’t quite living up to the high expectations set by its 2019 predecessor. Despite the buzz surrounding the film and its star-studded cast, it’s currently facing a lukewarm reception from critics. As of now, the movie has dropped to a 39% rating on Rotten Tomatoes, putting it dangerously close to the ranks of some of DC’s lowest-rated films.
This highly anticipated sequel, released on October 2, takes some bold artistic risks. The darker tone, paired with unexpected musical elements, hasn’t landed well with everyone. While some praised the performances of Phoenix and Gaga, others found the film’s plot, pacing, and overall direction to be confusing. The 39% rating puts Joker: Folie à Deux just below Justice League (40%) and miles behind the original Joker (2019), which not only scored rave reviews but also stormed its way to a $1 billion box office haul.
So, what went wrong? One of the film’s most divisive aspects has been the musical direction, something quite different for a movie like Joker. Phillips’ decision to blend dark psychological drama with musical sequences left many scratching their heads. Some critics have also pointed to the film’s plot, saying it lacks the tight, character-driven storytelling that made the first movie so successful.
However, all hope is not lost! Despite the critical split, the performances of Phoenix and Gaga have received a fair share of praise. Fans of both actors continue to support the film, hoping it will resonate more with audiences than it has with critics.
As Folie à Deux heads into its opening weekend, with projections targeting a $140 million haul, all eyes are on the box office. Can it make a comeback and prove the doubters wrong, or will it remain one of DC’s more controversial films? Either way, fans and critics are watching closely, and only time will tell if Joker: Folie à Deux can pull off a theatrical redemption.